Take Action: Respond to Evening Chronicle misreporting of 16 February arrest

Today the Evening Chronicle published an article that misrepresents the arrest of Michael MacDonald (known to most people as Don) on 16 February, sacrificing facts to sensationalism. Mr MacDonald was served a fixed penalty notice under Section 5 of the Public Order Act, but has returned this notice to the court and has stated his intention to fight the charge.

The article claims that ‘Nick Forbes was threatened in the street’, ‘subjected to a tirade of abuse’ and ‘harassed’ by Mr MacDonald. The tagline of the photo in the print edition reads ‘Most marchers were peaceful on the save our services demonstration through Newcastle last Saturday’, which many people will read as implying that the actions of Mr MacDonald on the march were not peaceful. Not only has Mr MacDonald not been found guilty in court, but he has not even been accused of threatening Mr Forbes. The charges instead relate to a placard Mr MacDonald was holding, which was featured in this Sky News report as ‘creative’, but which it is alleged caused Mr Forbes alarm and distress. Mr MacDonald denies any intention to cause alarm or distress, has posted the fixed penalty notice back to the court and declared his intention to challenge the charges. Mr MacDonald states that on 16 February he approached Mr Forbes, showed him a banner and said ‘Have you seen this?’, referring to the banner, and continued: ‘You were made out to be saviour in the press today when you’ve left your city out to dry.’ This was all that he said, and he has not been accused of saying anything different. It is very poor journalism to describe this as a ‘tirade of abuse’ and threats. Nick Forbes is not a victim, and should not be presented as one by the Evening Chronicle – the people we should be concerned about are the thousands of Newcastle residents facing devastating cuts directed by Mr Forbes’ council. Mr MacDonald was merely speaking his mind, and exercising the right to challenge an elected representative that all of us should have.

The campaign is calling on people to contact the Chronicle to ask them to issue a public statement correcting the inaccuracies of their 23 February article. We hope that if enough readers show this is a matter they are concerned about, it will encourage the Chronicle to take action.

You can email the Editor of the Chronicle at: darren.thwaites@trinitymirror.com

Write a letter for the letters page to: ec.letters@ncjmedia.co.uk

And comment on the website version of the article here.

We encourage you to write your own letter, especially if you were on the march of 16 February, but if you would prefer you can use the model letter/email to the editor below:

Dear Editor,

I was very concerned to read your article of 23 February entitled ‘Security increased as Nick Forbes is threatened’. The article states as a matter of fact that Michael MacDonald threatened and abused Mr Forbes during his appearance at the 16 February demonstration against the local and national cuts to services and benefits, and implies in the photo caption that his actions were not peaceful. It is my understanding that Mr MacDonald has not been accused of making any threats, and denies the charges against him of causing intentional alarm and distress through the placard he was holding. The article is therefore factually incorrect and misleading, and I ask you to issue a public statement and apology in the online and print editions of the Evening Chronicle correcting this mistake, to make it clear what the charges are and that Mr MacDonald denies them.

Sincerely,

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Responses to the Press and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Take Action: Respond to Evening Chronicle misreporting of 16 February arrest

  1. T says:

    The article also purposefully downplays the size of the march. It was estimated by police (always a conservative estimate) as 1,500. The article states ‘hundreds’.

  2. martynjohn says:

    I’ve written a reply to their editor, stating my views on their duty to journalism being a failure due to the article in question. As soon as I get a reply (I won’t hold my breath) I’ll post it in a similar WordPress article and will share it via the S.O.S. Facebook page.
    Great article – keep up the good work – Martyn.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Have written to the editor asking for apology and clarifications on the meeting. Here is Macdonald in a recent interview: sounds like a very intelligent reasoning man.http://www.capitalfm.com/northeast/on-air/news-travel/local-news/protest-march-over-newcastle-council-cuts/. I heard there was a YouTube video of his encounter with Forbes but can’t find it.

  4. dominic says:

    What a clear example of class war. The criminal is portrayed as the victim and Don MacDonald sticking his neck out in defence of ‘some seven libraries…the City Pool and Turkish Baths, play services…arts budgets…cash for museums…Sure Start centres…and weekly bin collections’ is arrested and fined! Im sure the people of Newcastle are firmly on the side of Macdonald! The labour council and their media mouthpieces are outnumbered!

    Carry on the fight! Oppose all cuts!
    Solidarity from Glasgow

  5. David Warner says:

    It may be of interest to you all to know that Forbes is a so-called ‘graduate’ of the organisation Common Purpose – Google for more info. He took a ‘Matrix’ course in 2003/4 with the organisation on Tyneside – his behaviour, and in particular his OTT reaction to Don’s protest says a great deal about this organisation and its ‘trainees’.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s